The Emancipation movement – the struggle for legal and political equality of Jews in Europe – began in the 1820s and by the 1870s had achieved its goals. Yet by 1880 a strong anti-Semitic movement had arisen in the West as a reaction to the success the Jews had achieved there; while in Russia bloody pogroms had begun. It was against this background that Leon Pinsker, formerly a staunch proponent of the idea of Jewish emancipation in Russia, came forward with his opposing doctrine of “Autoemancipation”. The thrust of his visionary pamphlet was an appeal to Jewry to realize the futility of their emancipation efforts in Europe and to seek a solution in the founding of an independent Jewish state. Thus he anticipated the idea of political Zionism propogated a decade and a half later by Theodor Herzl.
In this collection of twelve essays, Jacob Katz postulates that, when viewed in historical perspective, the concepts of emancipation and self-emancipation are not mutually exclusive. Several early Zionists had dreamed of a Jewish state years before Pinsker and Herzl – not out of disappointment with emancipation but, rather, as its natural outgrowth.
The first section of this book, “Emancipation”, discusses Jewry and Judaism in the nineteenth century, religion in modern Jewish history, Judaism and Christianity as viewed against the background of modern secularism, and the influence of religion and society on each other. It also describes the German-Jewish ideal of social emancipation and provides historical observations on emancipation and Jewish studies.
The second section, “Self-Emancipation”, focuses on the Jewish national movement. The forerunners of Zionism, including Zvi Hirsh Kalisher, Yehuda Alkalay, and Moses Hess, are profiled. Also included are articles on Zionism in contemporary Jewish history, Zionism and Jewish identity, Zionism versus anti-Semitism, and Israel and the Messiah.
Self-emancipation, these essays demonstrate, represents both a partial denial and a partial incorporation of the principles of the Jewish emancipation movement.